Search the forums
Loading
Wood Floors
Thinking about installing hardwood. I can't decide whether to go with the 'real' stuff' of with engineered. I'm installing over a joisted subfloor so either one will work. Because the room is huge I want to go with wider and longer boards to avoid a checker board effect. So for price I think engineered might be cheaper. Also, I don't want that terrible hallow sound you can get from floors like those at the mall. Is that possible with engineered flooring.
Navigation
Forum Topics
Breaktime
Project House Q&A Photo Gallery General Discussion Construction Techniques Energy, Heating & Insulation Business Tools for Home Building Green Building Reader Classified Help Wanted Work Wanted Breaktime Fests The Woodshed Tavern The ArchivesHelp/Feedback
Forum Suggestions Feedback on Fine Homebuilding The Editor's CornerInspired House
General Discussion Reader Tips Interior Decorating Design Talk Building and Remodeling Ideas Kitchen and Bath Outdoor Living Material Choices Photo GalleryRecent Discussions
Over Wintering Crawlspace Foundation 13 replies
Pre-fab roof trusses, single gusset 12 replies
Will this floor hold 4 replies
Heating options for a small shop 25 replies
Shop layout tips 11 replies
$350 per 1,000 Bricks 12 replies
Why free estimates? 10 replies
Spline gun 21 replies
Caulking Drywall Corners 17 replies
ICF Any experiences? good, bad, etc. 42 replies
What's with "Post #blah blah blah"? 10 replies
new private message - 21 replies
Mollom CAPTCHA Trouble? 22 replies
Question for the editors. 7 replies
On Jigsaw Review 1 reply
Hi,Ya'll 3 replies
Removing Tile Easily and Cleanly 6 replies
basement to first floor fireplace 7 replies
3/4" hardwoods on a 5/8" OSB subfloor 12 replies
28ft Box beam 12 replies
SW Door Exposure 3 replies
Current Issue
Member Visits
xxPaulCPxx
-
40 sec ago

harryvermehren
-
22 min ago
sapwood
-
47 min ago

WAwebfoot
-
53 min ago
junkhound
-
1 hour ago

rdesigns
-
2 hours ago
oldhand
-
2 hours ago
Forum Updates
We are working on fixing bugs and upgrading Breaktime based on feedback from the community.
LATEST SITE UPDATES
1. Improved naughty-word filter (7/25)
2. Added Google Search bar to top block; disabled Drupal search bar (7/23).
3. Explained how to add a photo to a post (7/23).




(post #175881, reply #1 of 6)
Did you ever decide which way to go? I'm facing the same decision now. Had laminate in the past and not really a fan. But, someone I talked to said that you really should never have to refinish either engineered or pure wood floors. Wondering if anyone has had experience with hardwood and engineered wood and has a preference?
Engineered Floors (post #175881, reply #5 of 6)
The Engineered wood will hold up very well, and doesn't seem to have as much of drum sound as laminate. I prefer the engineered to solid hardwoods, mostly because of the cost. The engineered costs less, and looks just as good if installed right for the fifteen to twenty years it takes the finish to wear out. At that point you will have to decide whether to refinish or tear out and reinstall. I think that when the time comes I will probably tear out and reinstall new engineered hardwood. But, higher quality engineered has a thick enough wear layer that it should be possible to do a light sanding and refinish.
The laminate is drummy because it is typically a floated floor, and the whole thing acts as a sound board.
My personal preference is for a staple down engineered hardwood floor. The correct staplers are kind of spendy. But, you can buy used ones off eBay, and sell them when you are done, if you have to. I bought one used a few years back that had 10,000 staples with it. I've done quite a few floors since then and still haven't bought more staples.
There are a few places that rent them, and that might be the way to go, but be careful on how long you keep it for because the rentals can add up fast.
(post #175881, reply #2 of 6)
1165.2 in reply to 1165.1
Did you ever decide which way to go? I'm facing the same decision now. Had laminate in the past and not really a fan. But, someone I talked to said that you really should never have to refinish either engineered or pure wood floors. Wondering if anyone has had experience with hardwood and engineered wood and has a preference?
(post #175881, reply #3 of 6)
I am about to install wood floors in a new house and have been advised that the lumber liquidators prefinished floors are great and hold up. Some of them have a 50 year guarantee. the added advantage is that you do not have to finish them!
(post #175881, reply #4 of 6)
I had Mohawk wood floors put down five years ago. They were prefinished. I am
very happy with it.